March 23, 2023 11:32 AM | 2 min read. Boeing researchers found another lab result they could not replicate: While the GPS white paper reported a 96.24 percent reduction in Staphylococcus aureus in 30 minutes, Boeing engineers found no reductions in the bacteria in an hourlong test. On May 7, law firms representing a man who spent over $750 on a GPS air cleaner in Texas filed the fraudulent concealment lawsuit against GPS in U.S. District Court in Delaware. Because shes been pointing out that independent researchers have found results that dont support GPSs claims. The emails attached to the complaint show that Stephens was pushing to get media attention for his predetermined conclusions well before the test was concluded. DALLAS, March 23, 2023 /PRNewswire/ --GPS Air ("GPS") filed a stipulation of dismissal in Cause No. A Boeing study found the technology isn't effective enough to use on planes. The claim alleged that Molekule air purifiers are falsely advertised as able to clean the air of pollutants and viruses such as COVID-19. Asheville, NC All seven of GPSs air treatment systems, which include the GPS-FC48-AC, GPS-FC24-AC, GPS-DM48-AC, GPS-FC-3-BAS, GPS-IMOD, GPS-IRIB-18 and GPS-IRIB-36, utilize NPBI technology, the case says. Global Plasma Solutions (GPS) is suing her for $180 million. For the last year I have been tracking the exploding, unregulated IAQ industry. "The lawsuit is without merit and based on flawed research, and we will be filing a motion to dismiss the case in the coming days," a spokesperson for Global Plasma Solution said in a statement emailed to The Mercury News. 3101 Yorkmont RoadSuite 400Charlotte, NC 28208, Global Plasma Solutions, Inc.s lawsuit against Dr. Marwa Zaatari, D Zine Partners LLC, and enVerid Systems Inc. comes to a Resolution, Dallas, Texas (March 23, 2023) - GPS Air (GPS) has filed a stipulation of dismissal in Cause No. Terms and Conditions. The lawsuit goes on to challenge the companys claims that its air cleaning products can kill the COVID-19 virus. _______________________________________________________________________. The case looks to represent anyone in the U.S. who purchased Global Plasma Solutions needlepoint bipolar ionization air treatment products. Why? The proposed class-action lawsuit says GPS makes deceptive, misleading, and false claims about its products based on company-funded studies that are not applicable to real world conditions., A GPS spokesperson said the lawsuit is baseless and misleading and that the company will aggressively defend against it. The article concluded that the device in our testing was ineffective in addressing the air pollutants that its advertised to remove from the space, the claim states. The company noted its products met ASHRAEs zero ozone certification standards, something Triplett had noted in past presentations, as well. Test data was cherry picked while ignoring contradictory results. Given the specific environment this was tested in, the quality of the materials, and the method in which the virus was dispersed, it is safe to say that the bipolar ionization system used in this experiment has the ability to deactivate SARS-CoV-2 with the given ion counts, the Aug. 7 report from the third-party lab says. Aerospace giant Boeing tested two kinds of ionization technologies like those widely adopted in schools hoping to combat Covid-19 to determine how well each killed germs on surfaces and decided that neither was effective enough to install on its commercial planes. Since locations will vary, clients should evaluate their individual application and environmental conditions when making an assessment regarding the technologys potential benefits. Defendants profits over people scheme won the company acclaim, publicity, and generated hundreds of millions of dollars in sales at the expense of the Plaintiff and Class Members across the country, the claim says. Though Triplett noted the devices had met various safety standards reviewed by governmental agencies and a heating and air conditioning professional association, he said, in an abundance of caution, Newark Unified has decided to disconnect all these devices from our HVAC units until further notice.. Per the case, acetone, ethanol and toluene are toxic substances that can cause health issues ranging from nose, throat, lung and eye irritation to fertility issues, harm to unborn children, and damage to the brain, muscles, heart, liver and kidneys. Case Details Parties Documents Dockets. According to the lawsuit, independent studies cited in the case documents show that the products are not only ineffective at cleaning the air in real world conditions, but byproducts from the devices include the following harmful toxins: In addition to the above toxins, Dr. Marwa Zaatari, a mechanical engineer, expert on indoor air quality and member of the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) epidemic task force, also warns that ionizers have been shown to produce ozone and formaldehyde. GPS devices work in conjunction with HVAC systems to help improve indoor air quality using a unique and patented low energy, soft ionization technology application called Needlepoint Bipolar Ionization (NPBI). He also has a book on building science coming out in the fall of 2022. GPS claims that their NPBI products are able to reduce over 99% of the SARS-Co-v2 virus in the air. Not surprisingly, Elsevier recently published a second study by Stephens apparently trying to correct the missteps of the first, flawed study. Despite being presented with this evidence, Elsevier has yet to retract the Study. He added that Boeing researchers deemed the study inconclusive., Plaintiffs Complaint throws the proverbial kitchen sink at GPS in the hopes that something might stick, the air purifier company says in court documents filed May 24 as part of its motion to dismiss the proposed class action. Last summer, Global Plasma Solutions wanted to test whether the company's air-purifying devices could kill covid-19 virus particles but could find only a lab using a chamber the size of a. Your email address will not be published. The district said at the time the devices would be paid for out of CARES Act funds the district received. The ARPA Zone/Open Membership Discussion Forums, https://chimicles.com/global-plasma-investigation/. Did you buy an air purifier during the COVID-19 pandemic to ensure clean air in your home? 155. Gary Moody A company spokesperson noted GPS appreciates Newarks concerns and has reached out to share additional data and answer questions, as well as extended an offer to conduct onsite testing to verify the safety of this technology and the added benefits.. VerticalScope Inc. All Rights Reserved. People are scared because of covid, and they capitalize on it., In filing a motion to dismiss the case, GPS told the court the lawsuit was an attempt to distort the facts and assert baseless claims, doing grave damage to GPSs business in the process., The GPS court document also says the disclaimers on its website make it unreasonable for any consumers to believe that the efficacy demonstrated in GPS studies will necessarily be the same for their particular application., It asserts that most of the GPS statements identified in the plaintiffs lawsuit such as safe to use and cleaner air amount to non-actionable puffery as they are vague generalities and statements of opinion.. Covid-sniffing dogs can help detect infections in K-12 schools, new California study suggests Companies that make the air purifiers say they emit charged ions, or activated oxygen, that are said to inactivate bacteria and viruses in the air. Decide which cookies you want to allow. While the defendant represents that its NPBI technologywhich purportedly uses an ionization field to break down compounds into oxygen, nitrogen, carbon dioxide and water vaporcan clean the air and eliminate VOCs, a panel of scientists from three universities released an article in February 2021 in which they concluded that GPSs bipolar ionization technology was ineffective in addressing the air pollutants that its advertised to remove from the space, the suit says. Please review our Affiliate Link Disclosure for more information. When large corporations sue individuals for obscene amounts of money, they often do so with impunity. Rather, it trades one group of harmful chemicals for another group of harmful chemicals.. A proposed class action filed this week claims Global Plasma Solutions Inc. has misrepresented its commercial air treatment systems ability to clean the air of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and the virus that causes COVID-19. A University of Arizona lab test described in the Boeing study found that the GPS device showed a 66.7% inactivation of a common cold coronavirus on a surface after an hour of exposure at up to 62,000 negative ions per cubic centimeter. The roughly 5,500-student district bought GPS units for every school HVAC system, Triplett said in a March school board meeting in which he noted the technology arguably is much better than any filter. By May, he said in the memo the district had become aware of the lawsuit alleging the misrepresentation of the devices and would continue to monitor the situation. It adds that GPS is instilling customers with a false sense of security through misleading claims by overstating its products COVID-19 mitigation performance. Mills, Esq. Read more here: Camp Lejeune Lawsuit Claims. When typing in this field, a list of search results will appear and be automatically updated as you type. Global Plasma Solutions Inc. 3:21-CV-00884- M; Global Plasma Solutions, Inc. v. Marwa Zaatari, D Zine Partners LLC, and enVerid Systems Inc.; in the Northern District of Texas dismissing all claims with prejudice following the resolution reached as a result of continued talks following mediation. A proposed class action filed this week claims Global Plasma Solutions Inc. has misrepresented its commercial air treatment systems' ability to clean the air of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and the virus that causes COVID-19. Why? GPS and other manufacturers of NBPIs claim that their ionizers remove over 99 percent of SARS-CoV-2 particles from the air. And what does it say about your product when you sue an indoor air quality expert? . The class action was filed in Delaware on May 7 by lead Plaintiff Robert Garner who alleges that the company makes false, deceptive, and misleading statements that were mere puffery about the needlepoint bipolar ionization technology used in its devices. of The Mills Law Firm, and Steffan T. Keeton, Esq. We use cookies to improve functionality and performance, enhance user experience, and provide tailored content. The authors failed to install and utilize the GPS device in a manner recommended by the manufacturer, thereby tainting all their results and making it virtually impossible to assess the data in any meaningful way. This all comes as a proposed class-action lawsuit is accusing Global Plasma Solutions of making "false, misleading, and deceptive" claims, adding that its products "make the air worse for. stephen.white@globalplasmasolutions.com, Internet Explorer presents a security risk. THANK YOU FOR ADDING ME. The lawsuit claims that the defendants misrepresentations and false statements were woven into an extensive and long-term advertising campaign accelerating during the COVID-19 pandemic., People are being victimized by these companies for profit, said Mickey Mills, a Houston attorney for the plaintiff. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), First Republic Bank seized, sold to JPMorgan Chase, COVID: Newark school district to disconnect $360,000 air cleaning devices following lawsuit, Covid-sniffing dogs can help detect infections in K-12 schools, new California study suggests, Bay Area school enrollment plummets for the sixth year in a row. The aircraft builder wrote that air ionization has not shown significant disinfection effectiveness, the lawsuit said. Per the lawsuit, GPSs purportedly independent studies were actually company funded and failed to reflect real-world situations when it comes to COVID-19 transmission. International Committee of the Fourth International. Filtration, ventilation with outdoor air, and ultraviolet germicidal irradiation are methods that work. Global Plasma Solutions Inc v. D Zine Partners LLC et al (3:21-cv-00884), Texas Northern District Court, Filed: 04/19/2021 - PacerMonitor Mobile Federal and Bankruptcy Court PACER Dockets PacerMonitor A Fitch Solutions Service Features Plans & Pricing About His prior work has been seen in multiple Bay Area outlets, including SF Weekly, as well as on KQED and KLIV radio. A class action lawsuit has been filed in federal court in Delaware against Global Plasma Solutions Inc. ("GPSI"), accusing the company of making false and misleading claims concerning its Needlepoint Bipolar Ionization products. Learn more about the cookies we use. According to the lawsuit documents, GPS, which was founded in 2008, had a previous focus on providing energy savings solutions. It should just raise flags for absolutely everyone.. Experimental replication is an essential step of the scientific process to ensure that data, analysis and results are reliable. A lot of people that sell IAQ such as HVAC contractors rely on what manufacturers tell them. Check out our list of Class Action Lawsuits and Class Action Settlements you may qualify to join! In all, Superintendent Mark Triplett said during an April board meeting the district had purchased 556 of the devices and installed them for a total of $359,945. The use of this technology is not intended to take the place of reasonable precautions to prevent the transmission of disease. document.getElementById( "ak_js_5" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); @2023 Top Class Actions. 1:21-cv-00665-UNA, in the U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware. The lawsuit alleges, however, that GPSs representations failed to hold up when placed under the microscope by independent academic studies and industry watchdogs. Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG), HVAC (Heating, Ventilation and Air-Conditioning), Machine Tools, Metalworking and Metallurgy, Aboriginal, First Nations & Native American, "the prior statements by Dr. Zaatari at issue in this case do not apply to GPS and its technology and were not intended to apply to GPS or its technology", "it is my understanding that GPS uses soft ionization in its products and not hard ionization", "Dr. Zaatari does not endorse GPS or its products", "enVerid and GPS occasionally compete on projects with their different air cleaning technologies", "enVerid's technology is a sorbent media-based filtration system that removes a wide range of gaseous contaminants from indoor air in a manner that complies with ASHRAE's IAQ Procedure", "GPS's technology uses needlepoint bipolar ionization to remove particles, pathogens, and certain gaseous contaminants from indoor air", "enVerid does not endorse GPS or its products", "all prior statements by Dr. Zaatari at issue in this case were made independent of enVerid". Actions does not process claims and we cannot advise you on the Many schools used federal funds to purchase the products. It is important to comply with all applicable public health laws and guidelines issued by federal, state, and local governments and health authorities as well as official guidance published by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), including but not limited to social distancing, hand hygiene, cough etiquette, and the use of face masks. The following month, Boeing began its own testing of GPS devices and another kind of ionization technology. It also used a surrogate for the virus that causes Covid-19. Global Plasma Solutions has sued her and another air-quality consultant for criticizing their devices, according to Kaiser Health News. If their products really were so great, would they be facing both individual and class action lawsuits? The manufacturer disputes these claims. If you able, please help Marwa Zaatari fight this lawsuit. Nobody should be working for less than 48 per hour. 81. r/HVAC 12 days ago. Camp Lejeune residents now have the opportunity to claim compensation for harm suffered from contaminated water. I disagree; if you know anything about air purification you would agree with the lawsuit. Cision Distribution 888-776-0942 In all, the case claims Global Plasma Solutions (GPS) has placed profits over people by engaging in false, deceptive, and misleading advertising aimed at concealing from the public that the products are, in reality, incapable of performing as marketed.. Bill aims to boost salaries 50% by 2030, Future of state housing is at stake in UC ruling, governor says. This is intimidation, pure and simple. The suit also claimed the devices can actually make the air worse. But her goal is $400,000. This browser does not support PDFs. Docket (#1) COMPLAINT against Elsevier Inc., Elsevier LTD with Jury Demand ( Filing fee $ 402 receipt number ANCWDC-5410474), filed by Global Plasma Solutions, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A-Article and Supplemental Data, #2 Exhibit B-Letter from R. Muckenfuss to Q. Chen, #3 Exhibit C-Deposition Excerpts of Y. Zeng, #4 Exhibit D-GPS Third Party Testing Webpage, #5 Exhibit E-Email String . Global Plasma Solutions, Inc.'s lawsuit against Dr. Marwa Zaatari, D Zine Partners LLC, and enVerid Systems Inc. Comes to a Resolution. I dont normally post this kind of appeal in my articles, but this fight is important. by PRNewswire. Let us know in the comments section! Seiderman also said that Global Plasma Solutions had figured out how to do ionization with no harmful byproducts, another claim challenged by the lawsuit. In this case, Dr. Zaatari is not yielding. ABOUT GLOBAL PLASMA SOLUTIONS Founded in 2008, Global Plasma Solutions (GPS) is a leader in indoor air quality, with over 30 patents and 250,000 installations worldwide since its. The lawsuit lays out the following factual background: In March 2021, Elsevier published a study entitled, Evaluating a commercially available in-duct bipolar ionization device for pollutant removal and potential byproduct formation, (the Study) in the journal Building and Environment. The district spent nearly $360,000 on the devices, an April board presentation shows. Founded in 2008, Global Plasma Solutions (GPS) is a leader in indoor air quality, with over 30 patents and 250,000 installations worldwide since its founding, including in research labs, schools, universities, health care facilities and airports. For information on deleting the cookies, please consult your browsers help function. Allison A. Bailes III, PhD is a speaker, writer, building science consultant, and the founder of Energy Vanguard in Decatur, Georgia. In a Kaiser Health News article from early May, Marwa Zaatari a member of the Epidemic Task Force of ASHRAE, the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers raised doubt about the efficacy of the devices. Triplett did not respond to a request for an interview for this news article. Furthermore, harmful byproducts produced by the technology place the health and safety of millions of students and staff at heightened risk.