These results show the promise of the NeurocycleTM as a stress management and instructional efficacy support tool for educators that also provides a medium for measuring results and maintenance. And, possibly, if anything useful remains at all, to explain how and (hypothetically why) it can help people in problems in a similar way as the whole (without the debunked parts) seems to have helped some? 72(8): 2036-44. There is so much more evidence. As an aside, how do you factor in or out the general agreement that the things which men think are wise are plain foolishness; that spiritual things are not known by mind power?. According to Dr Bruce Lipton (The Biology of Belief, 2008), gene disorders like Huntingtons chorea, beta thalassemia, cystic fibrosis, to name just a few, affect less than 2% of the population. Give yourself grace, especially if your life is a little crazy at the moment! Learn the business strategies Dr. Lisa Teurset? In the introduction, the article mentions that CBT of any form is effective at 6 months compared with usual care, so the study is probably reflective of this broad treatment effect of any psychological intervention, which like I said, isnt particularly earth-shattering. Just because I did a bachelors degree in arts and did two papers in sociology doesnt make me a sociologist! I wish you all the best with your life and your health. Your comment on this research appreciated. This, in turn, increases our cognitive performance, boosting our mental and physical health by positively impacting the way our brain and body functions on a day-to-day basis. Answering Shapiro et al.s (2006) seminal call for a measurement that assesses not only mindfulness but also its necessary mediators self-regulation, resilience, reconceptualization, and exposure the Leaf Mind Management Tool was created. Robert Salpolsky PhD Stanford- looks into stress and health. Dr Leaf holds a 20-year old PhD as a sub-specialist speech pathologist. Throughout our research trial, we saw significantly positive changes in the experimental group on a cellular level (based on changes in telomeres, the caps on chromosomes), in electrical activity in the brain (based on QEEG-measured changes in the brain), in psychosocial profiling (based on changes in psychological scales and narratives), and in blood tests (including changes cortisol and homocysteine levels). PLoS Genet, 2013. She repeated the same statement in her most recent book so it is something she is confident in. Hi John, thanks for the reply. Is it through negative thinking patterns? Circulation, 2009. Arch Gen Psychiatry, 2001. The more than do, the quicker the truth can resist her lies, half-truths and fake science. You only need to read the reply that Dr Leafs husband wrote (https://cedwardpitt.com/2013/08/29/mac-leaf-responds-to-dr-caroline-leaf-serious-questions-few-answers/) to appreciate that they dont care what other people say, and neither do they have any interest in the truth. In this step, you will evaluate what you have written in step 3 and think about the new healthy thought you want to build. Dr Leaf is not theologically trained One of her supervisors was on the editorial panel of a small journal in South Africa, and thus Dr Leaf managed to get three articles published in this journal, all of which were based on her masters and doctoral research. 7(11): e1000363. So I sought alternative opinions, on the merits of Dr Leafs new doctrines, or enhancement to old doctrines. And I don't have to wait long to start helping people professionally. If thoughts have any effect on our health, they are artificially magnified by our clean water and sewerage systems. The goal of this step is to focus on and embrace what you are inputting into your brain through your mind by gathering awareness of the emotional and physical warning signals, as well as the behaviors and perspectives, you are manifesting. While Dr. All the best. Her claim that she could put mind over matter thoughts out there to keep her son safe and keep in contact with him is very new age, and fits in with other messages that she has previously given (at the church of TD Jakes, no less) ~ https://cedwardpitt.com/2016/10/19/the-secret-teaching-of-dr-caroline-leaf/. Respectfully, While there are many kinds of therapies and treatments designed to support educators, mindfulness has shown specific efficacy for teachers, students, and educational settings due to its ease of implementation and near immediate positive impacts. Do not lie in bed and worry about not sleeping, or panic about how you will feel the day ahead or whatever is going on in your life, and this will impact your mental and physical help and make you feel even worse the next day. I am sure a practitioner like you has to invest quite a bit o energy to keep up even for you! You will also learn how to detox your thoughts using her practical, detailed, and easy-to-use 21-Day Brain Detox Plan. And it all began here in this very Become part of a network of like-minded individuals and organizations. [20]. And not evidenced based in the powerful word of God , the author of science. Smashwords = https://goo.gl/kKl995 This information should be liberating for the Believer. I do appreciate you taking the time to comment. Unfortunately, several churches are using the videos as a small group series directed towards people with no scientific background and frankly its embarrassing and wrong to poach on those who deal with mental illness in particular and claim quantum physics or science says her claims are correct and you can will your way out of a health situation by thinking good thoughts. Could you compile a short document, say 10-20 pages, maybe quite dense, but coherent, possibly with references, where you would focus EXCLUSIVELY on what remains of Caroline Leafs teaching after what you have to debunk is debunked? Mental training via deep thinking and understanding to build memory and learning actually increases the numbers of neurons that develop in the brain, particularly when the training goals are challenging. Also, just quickly, I dont claim that Dr Leaf is a heretic. The International Agency for Research on Cancer and the World Health Organization has concluded that 80% of cancers are due to lifestyles and are not genetic, and they say this is a conservative number (Cancer statistics and views of causes Science News Vol.115, No 2 (Jan.13 1979), p.23). Its good that she provides a reference to her statement. Not surprisingly, that research wasnt published in a peer-reviewed publication. She laughs at how ridiculous it is that she never went to college but was given accreditation regardless She doesnt claim to be an expert on psychology but speaks from her own life and experience of scripture so its far more balanced and rational without claiming to be what youre not, I tried to contact her and received the answers you received referencing her website, As you also point out, many are helped by numerous ideology from all kinds of people it doesnt mean they are who they say they are, It would be far more credible if Caroline Leaf had the humility to change her claim and started saying I have a degree in speech pathology and Im passionate about this and this and this. Teachers were provided with webinars covering the rationale behind and 5-step process of the NeurocycleTM, a tool for mental health detoxing and management. Dr Leaf gives medical advice in her blogs and from the pulpit (despite not being qualified or licensed to do so), advice which goes against the published medical evidence and clinical guidelines. After all, as you correctly pointed out, it transcends all understanding. She talks very fast, Im sure its an intentional tactic to make it harder for most people to know theyre being fed a bunch of guess-work and fake science. By your logic, we should dispense with all scientific knowledge that we cant cross-reference with the Bible, but the Bible and science are not mutually exclusive. Again, please give your resource references for Dr Leafs quotes as I would like to see what she said. Youll also have to forgive my confusion, but Dr Leaf also wrote, Dr H.F. Nijhout (Metaphors and the Role of Genes and Development, 1990) genes control biology and not the other way around. So is she saying that genes DO control development? This is a progressive, forward-moving step, and is where you wire in the changes you want to see in your life. Scriptures are super clear about fear and the power of our thought lives. If you wish to read my story and to read what science and scripture say about mental health and illness, youre welcome to read my books: Kintsukuroi Christians Turning Mental Brokenness into Beauty is a book for Christians and their loved ones to better understand that mental illness doesnt have to leave us broken and useless, but that God can make us more beautiful for having been broken. I have not charged for my book, and I do not gain any revenue from either the WordPress site or the debunkingdrleaf.com website. Harv Rev Psychiatry, 2011. You may not have gained any benefit from medications or counselling, but millions of people around the world do, and when Dr Leaf erroneously criticises psychiatric drugs and instead, promotes her own patented placebo program, she is doing a gross injustice to those who believe her. By Dr Leaf may be currently working on some research, and if she is, great. The aim of this step is to focus on one thought, with all its embedded memories (which could be in the 10s, 100s or 1000s), asking what it is about, answering yourself and discussing this thought in depth. its always about the money. We were lead to believe she was a neiscientist! I experienced severe trauma through abuse two years ago and have not felt quite myself since then. When it comes to sleep, remember to avoid panicking when you cant fall sleep. I would greatly appreciate it if anyone can connect me to Dr Leafs formal writings (peer review). Over the past few decades, many studies have contributed to utilizing electroencephalography (EEG) measurements to assess mental health through correlations between historically pre-defined frequency bands in the power spectrum alpha, beta, delta, theta, and gamma and specific mental health conditions (Newson & Thiagarajan, 2019). Riegel, B., et al., State of the science: promoting self-care in persons with heart failure: a scientific statement from the American Heart Association. Data is analyzed by an independent research and analysis consulting firm, Elite Research, LLC (, The study will provide a detailed picture of changes in mindfulness, mind management skills, and mental-health-related issues in adult populations. I hope to provide factual knowledge so that people will have accurate information and the opportunity for informed choice. Would you care to explain the answer that Jesus gave to his disciples in the story of the man born blind in John 9:1-3, Now as Jesus passed by, He saw a man who was blind from birth. The dark triad. Write: in a metacog in your neurocycle journal. Thanks for your comment. Web798K Followers, 714 Following, 6,525 Posts - See Instagram photos and videos from Dr. Caroline Leaf (@drcarolineleaf) Youre welcome to review the body of my work in which I have justified each claim using scientific and scriptural references. Data collection happens within the app every 21 days for the 20 LMM items and the 8 pro-mindfulness factors as well as a web-based survey (. ) She specializes in cognitive and metacognitive neuropsychology. When it comes to our biology, it is so important to remember that everything is connected,and that we should always take a holisticapproach when it comes to our mental and physical health, and avoid magic bullets and one-shot wonders. Continued research will increase the number of participants to assess continuance of the correlations amongst a larger sample. 25. I hope youre able to gain a much deeper understanding of all facts in the future. Who is your author of Science? This will bring a degree of closure in your mind, enabling you to compartmentalize your thoughts and sleep well. Participants feedback revealed that the program made it easy to apply their learning in their work and school lives, and that they desired further future mindfulness trainings via this program structure. Preliminary results from our trial also demonstrated a significant reduction in depression and anxiety, through mind-management, by up to 81%, in the experimental group compared with the control group. Dr Amua-Quarshies CV is certainly very impressive, no doubt about that, although he doesnt list the papers hes published. Granted there are some strange ministries out there and we need to be aware, but from what I understand, Dr. Dr Leafs teaching contradicts real science The other thing I was wondering about is why you blame yourself for your condition? I downloaded your ebook about Dr. Have a great day!! Why? Go look up the CDCs ACE study on trauma and stress causing diseases. Finally, your straw man argument about the author of science really doesnt carry any weight. I might be inclined to read your posts if you could mister some concise points. However positive affect and emotional reactivity was significantly reduced in the institutionalised children [25]. This is why I constantly emphasize getting to the root of our toxic stress and reconceptualizing negative thinking patterns in my research and work, and is why I created my appSwitch, which is based on my scientifically-researched 5-step program, and is designed to help you identify and detox the root of your toxic thoughts and help build healthy, new thinking habits in their place. And let us be open to Pitts questions- valid and in need of answers. This, in turn, impacts the way our body functions by impeding our ability to get nutrients from our food, which can set us up for all sorts of diseases (for more on the gut-brain connection, see my recent blogand podcast). A little background.. Dr. Caroline Leaf is a world-renowned cognitive neuroscientist, communication pathologist, and bestselling author with a Masters and Ph.D. in Communication Pathology and a BSc Logopaedics from the University of Cape Town and the University of Pretoria in South Africa, specializing in cognitive and metacognitive neuropsychology. I read it asking What are you I about lady?!! Spiritual truth comes through revelation, through the connection of the Holy Spirit and our spirit. Theres no stepping down going on here. She certainly profits off her cosy association with the Copelands and Joyce Meyer, but thats not why her teaching is wrong. Is it because you truly believe she is wrong and Im in danger, or is it something more? So, I wrote to Professor Howard Gardner who still works at Harvard University. SMOKING nicotine addiction has a strong hereditary link (50-75% genetic susceptibility) [10]. I welcome Dr Leaf to tender any further evidence in support of her claim. May Jesus bless us all in our sincere attempts to edify the saved and pre-saved!! A robust discussion provides the information required for people to make an informed choice. 9(1): 6-22. Thank you for your research and information. While Dr. For the benefit of Dr Leafs followers, and for the scientific and Christian community at large, I would appreciate your response. Leaf but this would seem to give weight to some of her claims. For instance, low gamma waves and high beta waves can be associated with ADHD and anxiety, respectively, while higher theta and alpha waves can reduce generalized anxiety disorder (Dadashi et al., 2015). Dr Leaf is not a cognitive neuroscientist. There is one annual four day intensive (32 hours) training course. I suffer from avoident personality disorder, depression, anxiety, social anxieties, all kinds of fun stuff. Writing things down is like putting your brain on paper, and helps to pull up buried memories from the nonconscious mind, adding clarity to what you are thinking about and allowing you to better see the area that needs to be detoxed by helping you to visualize your thoughts. Fowler, G., Evidence-based practice: Tools and techniques. Ronco, C., Fluid overload : diagnosis and management. Sid Roth I dont watch Sid Roth, though I have watched part of his interview with Caroline Leaf. I assumed much! So just relax, tell yourself you will eventually sleep, do something constructive, and make a plan to catch up on your sleep over the next few days. Dr Leaf has categorically stated that 75 to 98% of all illnesses are the result of our thought life on a number of occasions. You also say that Scriptures are super clear about fear and the power of our thought lives. Can you list which ones? And so are we!. http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=flame%20war. Dr Leaf is not guilty purely by association, she is just plain guilty. Again, I will discuss this further soon. This is my most popular post by far. Kunes, J. and Zicha, J., The interaction of genetic and environmental factors in the etiology of hypertension. Leaf is currently conducting and publishing clinical trials using the 5-step program she developed while in private practice to further demonstrate the effectiveness of mind-directed techniques to help relieve mental ill-health problems such as anxiety, depression and intrusive thoughts. Other than appearing on Sid Roths program (a red flag for me), I dont have any specific knowledge as to whether their teaching is legit. Dr. Leaf's research started 38 years ago with her masters thesis and her PhD dissertation work. From her graduate work, she moved to applied clinical work in the field with educators, students, government organizations, and patients in South Africa. Dr. You are essentially putting the thought on trial. In fact, the more you build your brain, the more confident, and less anxious, you will be when faced with a challenge! When it comes to our health, there are no shortcuts! And if anything, wrestling with our thoughts under the presumption that they are somehow toxic is actually counter-productive (https://cedwardpitt.com/2016/05/24/running-of-the-elephants-why-thought-suppression-doesnt-work/).
Does Girl Scout Cookie Money Go To Planned Parenthood, Gloria Ruiz Arredondo, Articles C